Pilgrim Tales: “Not All Who Wander”
“The Dean at Tulane thinks I’m the guy who decapitated their statue of the Virgin Mary, and I don’t know how to prove I’m innocent.” — From “Not All Who Wander”
“Not All Who Wander” was originally written some 8-10 years ago, and has been reopened and re-shelved countless times over the last decade. At the end of each revision session, I would stare at it and think, Well, this was fun, but I don’t know who would actually publish you. You’re so weird and Catholic. And back to the “shelf” it would go.
Until one time in 2022, I took it back out. I don’t remember why now, probably some submission opportunity that made me wonder if its quirky Catholicness would be welcome. I was sitting at my usual spot at the library. I had reached a writer’s block. I kept staring at the page re-reading the part that described the vandalized Marian statue. It used to be a statue on Loyola’s campus where Char and his friends would trespass in these vandalizing bouts. I, all of a sudden, felt a severe nagging sensation and couldn’t pinpoint where it was coming from.
Then the thought came to me: Not that statue.
I thought, What?
Again: Not that statue.
Again and again: Not that statue.
I felt like it was Mary speaking to me – commanding me – to change the statue. Why would Mary care about what fictional statue I was using in this college-centered bizarre story?
Unless … unless she doesn’t want the statue to be fictional at all…
I started Googling. And I confess, I don’t remember how long I sat in that chair at the library staring out the window trying to figure out if I had gone insane or if Mary was really telling me to change which statue of her was vandalized in this old short story I had written, but eventually I found it. The Our Lady of Fatima Pilgrimage Statue. The true story of how that statue cried actual human tears in New Orleans.
And I heard her say, “Yes, this statue.” I thought, Wow! Okay, Mary. This statue.
I don’t remember how many days passed before I actually started working the Our Lady of Fatima statue into the story and tossing the fake Loyola statue out, but one morning I started to feel … nagged … again. I felt I needed to look at all the dates of when this statue had visited New Orleans. So, I did. And I found that it had visited New Orleans the same weekend I did back in the summer of 2021. I thought, Okay, Mary, that’s cool. Thanks. The nagging sensation continued. I started scrolling through pictures from that trip. This picture popped up. Of a statue … an Our Lady of Fatima statue … that I had taken. I thought, No. There’s no way.
Quick back story: when my husband and I go on a trip, we try to incorporate a day where the two of us go on small Catholic

The International Pilgrim Virgin Statue of Our Lady of Fatima on her visit to St. Patrick’s Church, New Orleans, July 2021.
pilgrimages throughout the city that the rest of our travel party might not particularly care about. This was my husband’s first trip to New Orleans. So, he requested to go to the cathedral where his grandparents wed. We had already found several “God winks” about this church that were special to us and our relationship and we thought, Wow, how special that this is the church where they wed. I remember snapping a picture of the Our Lady of Fatima statue thinking how beautifully it was placed on the altar but not remembering any signage or anything indicating why it was on the altar at that time.
When I find the picture, I call the church office. The receptionist answers. I say, “Hi. I have an odd request. Are you particularly busy at the moment?” She gets just as invested as me. She has no idea if that statue in my picture is the same pilgrimage statue but promises to go investigate. She calls back, sounding breathless, “Yes! It’s that pilgrimage statue. It was here on that day thatyou visited!”
I was speechless. How did I end up here? What does it all mean?
As usual with the Lord, His mother, and their humor, I still don’t know what it all means. I just know that I wrote this story, and it’s set in New Orleans, and the statue in the story is real. I’ve seen it on a pilgrimage myself.
I’d like to think Mary was saying, “If you’re going to have someone vandalize a statue of me fictionally, make it count.” Clearly, she’s used this statue to speak to the people of New Orleans before. Beyond that, I don’t know.
The fact that this story ended up perfectly fitting the “fictional short story about a Catholic pilgrimage” niche of this anthology’s theme is beyond me. But, I’m happy to have placed it where it belongs, and I can only hope I did what I was supposed to do in revision. The rest is up to the reader.
If you’d like to read more by Rietta or connect with her, you can visit https://riettaparker.com.
Read “Not All Who Wander” and other short stories by the Catholic Writers Guild in Pilgrim Tales: a Catholic Writers Guild Short Story Anthology available now on Amazon in print and e-book.
© Copyright 2026 by Rietta Parker.
Feature photo of the French Quarter from pixabay.com
Inset photo by Rietta Parker. Used with Permission.


Image by Karolina Grabowska from Pixabay
2025 Margaret King Zacharias







