Question: Does Safety trump Forgiveness?
Maybe this is not the proper forum for this but I need some input from traditional minded Catholics about something that has been eating away at me. I need some different (if possible) takes on this and, out of desperation, thought I would take a shot and throw it out here. What better place than the CWG, right?
Okay, here goes. In their justified and necessary quest to prevent further scandals in the church the USCCB adopted the Charter for the Protection of Children & Young People (including vulnerable adults) which was modeled after guidelines established by the Dallas Charter of 2002. The bishops had to act and they did a marvelous job addressing the issues and implementing safeguards etc. So, what is my problem?
As a Eucharistic Minister who visits the home bound I was required to go through a two phase process to remain eligible to continue in this ministry. Part A) was a level 2 background check which included complete fingerprinting run through the FBI data-base. Part B) was the requirement to attend a “safe environment” training seminar. At this seminar a packet of various papers was handed out and included in these papers were three sheets listing 47 different offenses that immediately eliminated a person from any diocesan job (paid or volunteer) where children or vulnerable adults might be. Then one of the moderators happily explained how the FBI check had turned up a man with a DUI from 20 years earlier and how he was immediately relieved of his volunteer position as a school bus driver for field trips and other functions. This guy had not had a drink or been in any trouble since the DUI. I immediately was upset with this and asked about “forgiveness” and was told that “we HAVE to protect the children”. Look, I’m a parent and a grandparent. I know about protecting kids. This to me was over the top.
Second case had to do with a 29 year old man who I know very well. This guy has a learning disability and was hired as a dishwasher at a local Catholic high school. His problem was that, when he was 19, he and some of his teen aged buddies got drunk and this guy passed out behind a local restaurant. His friends left him there, the manager saw him and called the police and when the police tried to wake him he shoved the one cop. Result: “resisting arrest” and “battery on a police officer”. The FBI check pulled up these charges and he lost his dish washing job, just like that. Since then he has wound up being treated at the local mental health clinic and is severely depressed and on medication.
My question to anyone who may read this is; Does “Safety trump Forgiveness”? Did Jesus tell the woman caught in adultery to “go and sin no more but stay away from kids and vulnerable adults for the rest of your life”. I don’t think so. Your convicted pedophiles and sexual deviants cannot be allowed around kids. That’s a no-brainer. But, have we stepped over the line with this and are we, as catholics, unforgiving those who have charges against them that can be of no threat to anyone. Safe Environment predicated by Zero Tolerance seems to me to be a tool that can only lead to disenfranchising many catholics and even causing scandal by rejecting forgiveness. Help me out here, PLEASE.

